Apple Valley Ohio Lake Community by Sam Miller


Big Banks Accused of Short Sale Fraud

This article is worth reblogging because it can help real estate professionals and help educate sellers of this potential pitfall.

Diane Olick is CNBC’s Real Estate Reporter.  She writes her blog titled “Realty Check.”  Her article below was published last Friday, January 15.  It was so compelling that I wanted to share it with my readers who may have missed it.



Just as regulators, lawmakers and all forms of financial oversight boards are talking about new regulations to guard against mortgage fraud and another mortgage meltdown, there appears to be yet a new mortgage fraud out there today, allegedly perpetuated by agents of, yes, the big banks.


I was first alerted to this by Jeremy Brandt, the CEO of several companies that bring short sale agents, investors and sellers together.


His companies include 1800CashOffer, and Brandt has a huge network of short sale real estate agents, and over the past several months he's been receiving all kinds of questions and complaints about trouble with second lien holders.


As we all know, during the housing boom, millions of Americans pulled cash out of their homes in the form of home equity loans and lines of credit. They also used "piggy back" loans in order to get even lower interest rates on their primary mortgages. Now, many of the borrowers in trouble, and many who are so far underwater on their loans that they don't qualify for any refi or modification, are choosing short sales as a way out. (Short sales are when the lender allows the home to be sold for less than the value of the loan).


About 12 percent of all home sales by the end of 2009 were short sales, according to the National Association of Realtors.


In order for a short sale with two loans to happen, the second lien holder has to drop the lien.


If they don't, and there's no short sale, the home goes to foreclosure and the first lien holder gets the house because second liens are subordinated debt to the primary loan.

In short, the second lien holder gets nothing. In order to get the second lien holder to drop the lien, the first lien holder generally negotiates some partial payment to the second lien holder. The second lien holder doesn't have to agree, but more and more are doing so.


That's all legal.


But here's what's not legal and what's apparently happening quite often recently. Since many second lien holders are getting very little, they are now allegedly requesting money on the side from either real estate agents or the buyers in the short sale. When I say "on the side," I mean in cash, off the HUD settlement statements, so the first lien holder doesn't see it.


"They are pretty clear and pretty upfront about the fact that if the first lender knows they are getting paid, the first lender will kill the short sale," says Brandt. "So these second lenders are asking for the payments off the closing documents, off the HUD statement, usually in a cashiers check prior to closing. Once they receive that payment, they will allow the short sale to go through, which according to RESPA laws and the lawyers that we have spoken to on the topic is not legal."


(RESPA is the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, the 2008 law requiring that consumers receive disclosures at various times in the transaction. It outlaws kickbacks that increase the cost of settlement services. RESPA is a HUD consumer protection statute designed to help homebuyers be better shoppers in the home buying process, and is enforced by HUD.


I told RESPA specialist Brian Sullivan over at HUD about all this and he replied, "That's a red flag!"


Clearly illegal.


Brandt told me he's heard from at least 200 agents that they've had these requests made by representatives of Citi Mortgage, JP Morgan Chase, Bank of America and other large banks.


Most agents wouldn't go on the record with me, for fear of retribution by the banks with whom they have to work every day. But one agent, Kayte Gentry, of Keller Williams Integrity First Realty, was brave enough to blow the whistle.


"I think it's wrong, and I think somebody needs to hold them accountable, and every time I lose a house in foreclosure because of this, it hurts my client," says Gentry matter-of-factly. "Aside from being illegal and a violation of RESPA, it's immoral and truly it's just sad for the client that it's hurting."


Gentry says she has had the requests made three times and claims she lost one sale because of it.


"The big banks that have recently made this request, specifically payments outside of the closing statement have been Citi Mortgage and JP Morgan Chase."


JP Morgan Chase simply answered, "No Comment," when I relayed the charge to their media representative.


Bank of America denied the practice to CNBC in a written statement:


"Bank of America enforces a policy that all disbursements are documented on the settlement statement for short sales. When we are servicing a first mortgage with a second lien held by another investor, if the second lien holder asks for off-HUD payments, we will not approve the transaction (if we have knowledge of it). It is also against Bank of America’s policy to accept off-HUD payments on its second liens."


Citi 's reply was a bit more complicated:


“We work very hard to help distressed homeowners find solutions for their financial challenges. In our attempt to amicably resolve the debt, we will generally negotiate a reduced settlement with the homeowner in order to release a second lien. Unlike some lenders who refuse to reduce the payoffs on second liens, we choose to reduce the payoff amounts in some situations to assist the borrower. We do not provide instructions to settlement agents on how to fill out the settlement statement or any other closing documents, and we certainly do not require settlement agents or any other parties to violate applicable laws."


"When we confront the lenders and tell them that this request is illegal and a violation of RESPA, they tell us it's been cleared through legal and they don't care. Do it anyway," charges Gentry.


I personally heard a recording of a phone conversation between a short sale real estate agent and a second lien lender, during which the second lien lender clearly asked for cash outside of the settlement and threatened to kill the deal without it.


The real estate agent was rightly concerned and reluctant (the recording was given to me by Brandt who got it from the agent. The agent would provide no information on the lender, for fear of retribution):


AGENT: Well yes, I don’t want to lose my license, go to jail, I mean, I have to sign…


LENDER: You're not going to lose your license - we have plenty of realtors who do this, who actually understand how this whole process goes - and they realize that OK, if I want to get this done, this will take place."


I contacted the Treasury Department, HUD, FINCEN (Financial Crimes Enforcement Network) and the Federal Trade Commission, and none of their representatives could tell me of any active investigation into this.


The folks at HUD said they'd be very interested to see my story.


By: Diana Olick
CNBC Real Estate Reporter


Comment balloon 4 commentsSam Miller • January 29 2010 07:47PM
Big Banks Accused of Short Sale Fraud
This article is worth reblogging because it can help real estate professionals and help educate sellers of this potential pitfall. Diane Olick is CNBC’s Real Estate Reporter. She writes her blog titled “Realty Check. ” Her article below was… more
Mount Vernon, Ohio Home for $100, 000 (SOLD)
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 1013 West Chestnut Street, Mount Vernon, OH Stylish Upgrades That Are Beyond Impressive! .. more
Mount Vernon Ohio South End Brick Ranch at 118 Ames Street
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 118 Ames Street, Mount Vernon, OH Mount Vernon Southend Brick Ranch 2BR/2BA Single Family House offered at $105, 000 Year Built 1963 Sq Footage 1, 102 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms 2 full, 0 partial… more
Apple Valley Lake Real Estate Opportunity at 30 Valleyview Court (off…
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 30… more
Mount Vernon Ohio Condo (New Price)
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 503 East Gambier Street, Mount Vernon, OH Mount Vernon Ohio All Brick Condo 2BR/2BA Condo offered at $125, 000 Year Built 1982 Sq Footage 1, 234 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms 2 full, 0 partial Floors 1… more
Mount Vernon Ohio Home For Sale at 305 Martinsburg Road (SOLD)
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 305 Martinsburg Road, Mount Vernon, OH House Plus A Unique Garage Apartment 3BR/1+1BA Single Family House offered at $85, 000 Year Built 1916 Sq Footage 2, 000 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms 1 full, 1… more
33 Mallard Pointe in Mount Vernon, Ohio
High quality custom home with a pond view in Mount Vernon, Ohio. Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 33 Mallard Pointe, Mount Vernon, OH Stylish and High Quality Features 3BR/3BA Single Family House offered at $259, 900… more
Apple Valley Lake Home Search
Searching for a home at the Apple Valley Lake has never been easier when you utilize our automated home search system at AppleValleyOhio. com This free service will help you find your Apple Valley dream home quickly and easily. This… more
Eastern Knox County Log Sided Country Home at 324 Pine Street (off…
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 324 Pine Street, Brinkhaven, OH You'll Love The Look and Feel of a Log Sided Home 3BR/2+1BA Single Family House offered at $155, 000 Year Built 1998 Sq Footage 2, 245 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms 2… more
Fredericktown Ohio Home at 5 East Mound Street
Sam Miller | RE/MAX Stars Realty | (740) 397-7800 5 East Mound Street, Fredericktown, OH 4BR/2BA Single Family House offered at $139, 900 Year Built 1958 Sq Footage 1, 794 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms 2 full, 0 partial Floors 1 Parking 2 Car garage… more